calendar >>>
> Sharon Stone sexy mo…
> G20 Benefit
> G20 Arrestees Benefi…
> G20 Arrestees Benefi…
> G20 arrestee support
add an event >>>
features
   anti-war
   migration
   climate change
   ecology
   students
   work
   health
   gender
   culture
   indymedia
   global news
   anti-nuclear
   anti-racism
   civil liberties
   anti-corporate
   miscellaneous
   social movements

 

announcements list
contributors list

about us
   contact
   get involved
   support us
   editorial policy

resources
   activist groups
   syndication
   links

radio
podcast

engagemedia

search


themes
   white theme black theme




 

 

 


printable version - email this article

The Age's coverage of G20
by Anna Krien Tuesday November 21, 2006 at 11:06 AM
annakrien@hotmail.com

In response to The Age's coverage prior, during and post this week's G20 protests I wrote this opinion piece intended for The Age newspaper. While there was a willingness to publish it in today's newspaper (21/11), the head editor Andrew Jaspan stepped in and demanded it not be published.

The Age’s reporting of the past week’s protests against the G20, as well as its white picket-fence style mockery from columnist Jonathon Green (17/11), can be summed up with a discussion I had with a photographer from The Sunday Age as we leant against the plastic barricades in Russell Street with four tiers of police wearing reflective sunglasses beyond us. After watching him take several photos of a Hare Krishna man wearing a rainbow sarong and waving a crystal, I asked the photographer if that was the kind of photo he was planning to file to his editor. In typical tabloid digression, the photographer accused me of suggesting this particular man was an inferior representation of the protest. No, I replied, but it is a rather easy photograph isn’t it? Especially when right next to this particular photographer stood an architect, teacher, chemist and a writer, boringly clad in non-outrageous clothes.

Luckily this Hare Krishna fellow didn’t make the cut for The Sunday Age – because luckily, violence ensued, unbeknownst to the two thousand non-violent protesters who were crammed into one city block. Arterial Block’s behaviour reminded many fellow protesters of something, what was it? Oh yes – Friday night drinks perhaps? As for Commissioner Christine Nixon’s comment about Saturday’s protesting being the worst violence she has seen in Melbourne for the past six years, well some of my closest girlfriends have experienced worse violence during such Friday night drinks.

Before the press responds to this by rolling out its tired ‘what do you want – censorship?’ argument, I’d like to say that responsibility is not censorship and perpetuating stereotypes is not reporting. At the end of the discussion between The Sunday Age’s photographer and myself, he blurted like a pigeon losing its puff, “Well I’m just doing my job, aren’t I?” To which I can only say sadly “No, you are not.”

As for ‘colour’ writer Jonathon Green’s notebook on the general hilarity of the usual loonies and peace seekers who come out of the woodwork when something important is happening in this very city - and no, I do not mean the AFL Grand Final, rather just a few political heavyweights who talk over our heads like we’re children, plus token representatives from the third world. There is nothing skilful about satire that takes a stab at people who are unprotected by massive public relations bodies, not to mention a riot squad.

Lastly why laugh at the G20 protesters? Mock us? Spread hyperbolic rumours that we will be violent, dear media, were you trying to provoke us into a fury the week prior? Would you be more proud if your children did not care? Also you might add to each other – it’s amazing what these kids do in the face of such derogatory backlash and comment, I mean at least we (you) get paid for it. All this talk about the ‘militant youth’ trashing Australia – that is absurd. I have never met a people more passionate about this country. That is the country that is like some deformed creature locked in the basement, its identity denied while certain politicians parody it on a world stage.

After the protest (the peaceful one that was quite big, but not violent so you may not have heard about it) three friends and myself were thirsty. It was a strange moment when we realised there were four 7 Eleven convenient stores around us like the points of a compass. It was difficult to work out which one was closest – they all seemed so upon us.

add your comments


LATEST COMMENTS ABOUT THIS ARTICLE
Listed below are the 10 latest comments of 8 posted about this article.
These comments are anonymously submitted by the website visitors.
TITLE AUTHOR DATE
Remember... Granny Smith Tuesday November 21, 2006 at 04:56 AM
THE AGED? your living in the past, man! Tuesday November 21, 2006 at 12:14 AM
Argus stuffed pro2rat@etc Monday November 20, 2006 at 10:11 PM
Urine vik Monday November 20, 2006 at 09:35 PM
Nice article . Monday November 20, 2006 at 09:03 PM
Maybe ... Disgusted Monday November 20, 2006 at 08:26 PM
great piece terry Monday November 20, 2006 at 07:20 PM
Well put despite not being published Outer Aged Monday November 20, 2006 at 07:14 PM
Melbourne Indymedia is a website produced by grassroots media makers offering non-corporate coverage of struggles, actions and celebrations. Everyone is a witness. Everyone is a journalist.
N© Melbourne Independent Media Center. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by the Melbourne Independent Media Center.